Ask Shift of Tow
Thursday, July 31st, 2008I can’t fathom why my brother is engaged to his fiancee. It’s an extreme example of opposites attract. She’s not a bad person, just unfathomable. She is much younger than him (7 years) and in her early twenties. I predict heart break. Is there a good way of counseling my brother out of this? Or maybe it’s none of my business? There is no date for the wedding set yet, thank god.
Here’s one true thing I know about other people’s relationships: We don’t know what’s going on inside them.
We think we do, and this is especially true if we’re in a relationship with which we’re happy. We think that since we have a great relationship, we have the secret to how anybody can have a great relationship. It’s kind of crazy how we all seem to hold this idea that we’re unique and that we also know what everyone else ought to be doing in our heads at the same time.
This is not to say I think it’s none of your business, but that maybe it’s not the problem you see it as being. Maybe you’re right, maybe it’ll end in heartbreak, but maybe it won’t. If it does, maybe heartbreak is what he needs, and maybe when it comes, it will be time for it. Your brother might need something from relationships that you don’t see or understand. He might need her to be pretty, because maybe he cares what other people think about who he’s with. He might need her to be a little bit dim, so he’ll feel smart. He might need her to be an artist, even if she’s a bad one, because that’s what he longs for in a mate. He might need her to be tall, or short. He might just need her to love him without any judgment, because maybe we all go through phases like that, where we need to be loved more than we need to be fulfilled. You might see these needs as wrong, as immature, something which he’ll outgrow. But that’s who he is right now. The point is that whatever has him with this girl isn’t just that he doesn’t see her, er, lack of fathomability, but that he needs something she’s giving him–that’s about what he is, and not just about the relationship.
The thing about advice—and I recognize the irony in my saying this here—is that the person to whom you want to give advice has to be ready for it if it’s got a deadline, or it has to be advice that they can save up for later. Most people are not ready for timely advice when they’re in the middle of doing something that isn’t quite right. All you’ll get if you tell him not to marry this girl is the ability to say “I told you so” if and when it falls apart. It’s not going to prevent the marriage; it’s not going to change his relationship.
Here’s a suggestion: Try to figure out why he wants to marry her. Don’t ask him directly, because it’s going to be hard to do that without letting on that you think it’s a bad idea. Just listen and watch. It’ll help you know your brother a little better, and settle your mind at the same time.
I hope that helps.




















